1965 Sportster Project
Text and Pictures by Mark Trotta
When new, the 1965 Sportster XLCH was the fastest production motorcycle on the planet. It was a flat out, built for speed, no-frills hot rod, not much more than two wheels, a seat and a 900cc engine.
1965 Sportster Production: 2,815 XLCH models, 955 XLH models (3,770 total units)
The Back Story
Around 2005, a fellow named Karl was unhappy with the way his 1965 Sportster ran. He took it to a local bike shop for a repair estimate. After the engine was completely disassembled and inspected, the shop owner gave him an estimate of $4,000 to make everything right.
After declining to have the work done, he was given two options; pay $1,000 to have the engine re-assembled, or carry out everything in boxes. He decided to carry out everything in boxes.
After sitting disassembled in his shed for ten years, Karl decided to sell the bike.
In 2016, I was glancing through some motorcycle project ads, and came across "1965 Sportster For Sale". It so happened that Karl and I lived in the same state, so I emailed him a few questions.
He responded several days later, saying that the engine had already been sold, but the rolling chassis was still available. So I hopped in my truck and drove three hours there and three hours back to buy the rolling chassis.
Several months goes by, and I receive another email from Karl. Seems there was a dispute over shipping costs between him and person who was buying the Sportster motor. He asked if I was still interested in the motor.
So, I hopped in my truck, made another six-hour round trip, and picked up the Sportster engine.
Sportster In A Box
The disassembled motor was packed up in a large wooden crate, ready to be shipped. It must have weighed 300 pounds - not something I'd want to pay shipping on.
After driving home and unloading the crate, I spread the engine parts out on my garage workbench and made an inventory of all the parts. Just about every piece of the motor was there, including nuts, bolts and hardware.
Right-Side Case Damage
The right-side engine case had a circular crack where the generator mounted, presumably from the bolts being over-tightened.
The generator hole repair was very time-consuming, but necessary to keep the numbers-matching cases.
Left-Side Case Damage
Internally, the left-side case was OK, but there was a 2" chip missing where the primary cover bolts up. Both engine case repairs were TIG welded.
Read: Repair Cracked Cases
Original Factory Finish On Engine
For an authentic and correct motorcycle restoration, the factory finish should be left on engine cases. Most are quite hard to duplicate, so sanding down original cases is not a good idea.
Unfortunately, these cases had been painted black somewhere in the past. So without really having any other choices, I sanded off the black paint after the cases were repaired. This was very tedious and time consuming, because Ironhead engine cases have plenty of nooks and crannies.
Crank And Flywheel Build
After rebuilding the flywheel assembly I trued it on my homemade stand. This was another time-consuming part of the engine rebuild.
Read: Ironhead Flywheel Rebuild
I also used my DIY truing stand to check straightness on the pinion shaft and sprocket shaft.
The lower end rebuild was finally complete.
Engine Clearances Before and After
Mock-building the motor was necessary for several reasons. First, motorcycle engine clearances should be measured before disassembly. But when you start with a completely disassembled motor, you don't have that opportunity. This required the additional steps of assembling the engine to get the "before" measurements, then disassembling, repairing/replacing, and re-assembling.
Cams And Cam Cover Issues
Another reason for mock-building the motor was to check all parts were in proper working order. The cam cover did not go on and off easily like it should, indicating a cam mis-alignment was likely. This led me to find one of the cams was binding. After testing each cam individually with the other cams, I found out which one it was, and replaced it.
Read: Install Sportster Cams
Restoring Aluminum Engine Parts
The pitting and corrosion seen on these old parts is typical for a 50 year-old unrestored motorcycle. I sent the cam cover, primary cover, and rocker boxes out to have the old chrome removed.
Six weeks later, when the parts returned, I began sanding and polishing them.
Read: How To Polish Aluminum Motorcycle Parts
Replace Cam Bushings
The cam cover bushings were replaced due to contamination from the acid after de-chroming.
Read: Remove/Install Sportster Cam Bushings
Broken Valve Spring
One of the old valve springs (don't know off which valve) had cracked in two pieces. Since I had no prior history of the engine, I could only speculate why. The most likely cause would be over-revving.
Both cylinder heads were rebuilt, which included new valves, guides, and springs, and a three-angle valve job. All four rocker arms were replaced.
Early Ironhead Transmission
Like the rest of the motor, the transmission was completely disassembled when I bought it. Fortunately, I had a complete transmission from another Sportster, which I used as a reference to put this one back together.
Rebuilding an Ironhead transmission is a project within a project. It took a while, but the results were good. Clearances are in tolerance and it shifts fine.
Read: Remove and Install Ironhead Transmission
1965 Sportster Project Update (January 2020)
This motorcycle project has been an enlightening and humbling experience for me. Working on the engine on and off between other projects, I have somehow managed to invest over 100 hours into it.
Financially, it would have been more profitable for me to part the bike out, but I couldn't have done that. Not to a low production-year motorcycle with matching case numbers.